SUCCESS STORY · SQUARE ONLINE · OCT 2, 2026

Popped Fresh for Opening Day: Hill City Popcorn Co. Goes Gifting-First on Square Online 🍿

A new home in Tontitown, a cleaned-up Square catalog and a store built for pickup, drive-thru, nationwide shipping and a monthly subscription.

Hill City Popcorn Co. product page for Hattie’s, with size options and store pickup on Square Online

One kettle. Endless possibilities.

A Northwest Arkansas Favorite Starts a New Chapter

Hill City Popcorn Co. has been hand-popping small-batch gourmet popcorn in Northwest Arkansas for over 10 years, from Caramel Pecan to Dill Pickle to the house favorite, Hattie’s. In 2026, Matt and Jessica Boring took over the business and moved it from Fayetteville into a new shop in Tontitown, with an open kitchen where you can watch every batch being made.

The fourth quarter is when a popcorn shop shines: holidays, corporate gifts and tins by the dozen. With the grand opening set for Oct 1, Matt needed a website that could sell all of that from day one.

THE CHALLENGE

More Than a Popcorn Shop

Matt said it best: “I want Hill City to feel like a gifting brand — something people think of for holidays, corporate gifts, client gifts, events, weddings, thank-yous, and occasions throughout the year.” The site also had to stay simple for anyone who just wants a bag for pickup.

product

A Gifting Brand, Simple to Shop

The site had to sell gift tins and corporate orders without making a quick pickup order feel complicated.

POS

A Catalog in Knots

The old Square item library had grown to nearly 500 variations under an outdated size system, with many flavors listed more than once.

location

An Opening-Day Deadline

The new shop, the new website and the move off the old hosting all had to be ready for the Oct 1 grand opening.

WHAT WE BUILT

How We Got Hill City Popping Online

Step 1
Step 1

A Clean Square Catalog

We rebuilt the item library from scratch so the register and the website share one clean menu.

  • One item per flavor, with sizes as simple options
  • Tins and sampler boxes as single items with flavor pickers
  • Two ways to browse: by tier and by flavor profile, from Sweet & Fruity to Bold & Spicy
  • Search-friendly descriptions for every flavor, plus a reorganized POS layout
Step 2

A Gifting-First Website

Gifting leads the story, but ordering a single bag is still one tap away.

  • A coming-soon page that collected email sign-ups before the doors opened
  • A gifting page with a quote form for corporate and custom orders
  • Order for Pickup and Order to Be Shipped buttons right on the homepage
  • The domain moved off the old hosting into an account Hill City controls
Hill City Popcorn Co. homepage on Square Online, with Order for Pickup and Order to Be Shipped buttons
Step 3
Step 3

Pickup, Drive-Thru and The Monthly Pop

Local customers can order ahead and roll through, and regulars can subscribe.

  • Scheduled online pickup, with Square’s curbside option set up as drive-thru
  • A pop-up and a “How ordering works” section that explain pickup lead times
  • The Monthly Pop, a Square Subscriptions box that delivers two flavors every month
Step 4

Nationwide Shipping and Google

Gift tins can now travel anywhere in the US, and Hill City is easier to find.

  • Flat-rate nationwide shipping for gift tins and sampler boxes
  • A Shipping page, first in the menu, that explains when heat-sensitive flavors are held back
  • Google Business Profile, Search Console and Google Analytics connected
  • Step-by-step staff guides for pickup, shipping and shipped sales at the register
Hill City Popcorn Co. nationwide shipping page with buttons to order 2 gallon tins or a 2 flavor sampler box
Square Online
PLATFORM SPOTLIGHT

Why Square Online Works for Specialty Food and Gifting

When the same team runs the counter, the drive-thru and the shipping table, everything should come from one system.

One Menu Everywhere

The register and the website share the same items, sizes and sold-out status, so a flavor that runs out in the shop disappears online too.

Every Way to Order

Pickup, drive-thru and shipping live in one checkout, and each option follows its own rules and lead times.

Subscriptions Built In

Square Subscriptions turns regulars into monthly customers without adding another app to manage.

VIBE TIPS

Best Practices for Specialty Food Shops Selling Online

Lessons from Hill City’s launch for bakeries, candy shops, coffee roasters and anyone selling treats people love to give.

đź’ˇ Best Practice

Sell the Occasion

Gifts, thank-yous and corporate orders are bigger tickets than a single bag. Give them their own page and an easy way to ask for a quote.

đź’ˇ Best Practice

One Item per Flavor

Make sizes options instead of separate items. Your menu stays short, reports stay clean, and sold-out updates take one tap.

đź’ˇ Best Practice

Give Shoppers Two Ways to Browse

Some customers shop by size or price, others by craving. Let them filter both ways.

đź’ˇ Best Practice

Explain Lead Times Up Front

If orders need a few days, say so before checkout, not after.

đź’ˇ Best Practice

Ship What Travels Well

Limit shipping to items that arrive in great shape, and tell customers when heat-sensitive flavors will be back.

đź’ˇ Best Practice

Build Your List Before You Open

A coming-soon page with a sign-up form gives you an audience on opening day.

THE FINISHED SITE

Take a Look at the New Site

Hill City Popcorn Co. Gourmet Popcorn shop page on Square Online with category filters
The Monthly Pop subscription product page on Hill City Popcorn Co.’s Square Online store
THE RESULT

Fresh Out of the Kettle 🍿

Hill City Popcorn Co.’s new website was ready for opening week, taking pickup, drive-thru, shipping and subscription orders, and gifting requests started arriving through the site that same week.

One Clean Catalog

The counter and the website share one simple menu.

Every Way to Order

Pickup, drive-thru, nationwide shipping and The Monthly Pop, all on Square.

Ready for the Holidays

A gifting-first site going into the shop’s busiest season.

Hill City Popcorn Co. logo

More About Hill City Popcorn Co.

Hill City Popcorn Co. hand-pops small-batch gourmet popcorn in Tontitown, Arkansas, with classic, deluxe, house-mix and specialty flavors, gift tins and custom corporate gifting. Stop by the shop, grab an order at the drive-thru, or have a tin shipped anywhere in the US.

Visit Hill City Popcorn Co. →

Opening a Shop or Getting Ready for the Holidays?

Let’s get your menu, pickup, shipping and gifting working together on one Square system.

Scroll to Top